Featured image for the Luxury Homes for Sale in Shark Key, FL Community Guide Page
Credit: Image by Gene Gallin | Unsplash
Overview

Luxury Homes for Sale in Shark Key, FL

Shark Key is a private paradise and one of Florida Key’s most exclusive communities.

This long, narrow island offers unmatched peace, privacy, and luxury. It has two miles of pristine shoreline and lush tropical trees. All homes in Shark Key are exquisitely designed and face the beautiful waters of the Gulf of Mexico. Some properties back up to a serene saltwater lagoon on the other side, which provides panoramic vistas at every corner. For those seeking a custom-built retreat far from the usual bustle, Shark Key is a dream destination that feels like a hidden gem yet is still close to everything you need.

HIGHLY EXCLUSIVE: Shark Key offers exclusivity and intimacy that few places can match. There’s only one entry point, fully gated, ensuring limited access and a secure, tranquil environment. The small number of homes adds to the quiet, close-knit vibe, making the neighborhood feel like its own world. Each mansion sits on a generous lot, enhanced by lush tropical trees that add to the sense of seclusion. Despite all these, the community remains well-connected, with a direct connection to the Overseas Highway, making it easy to visit Key West.

LUXURY CUSTOM HOMES: Shark Key boasts some of the grandest open-water estates in the Keys. These custom homes impress with soaring ceilings, floor-to-ceiling windows, imposing staircases, and expansive open-concept spaces. Many feature chef’s kitchens, large bedrooms with en-suite baths, and private verandas. Watch sunrises or sunsets from your balcony, or head to the backyard and dip in the pool overlooking the Gulf. Several properties feature private shorelines and docks perfect for boating, paddleboarding, kayaking, and fishing.

EXCLUSIVE AMENITIES: Shark Key, Florida, brings luxury amenities right to your doorstep, creating a true resort-style experience. Dive into the refreshing saltwater lagoon or relax on the private, white-sand beach with a shaded pavilion, grilling area, and beach chairs. Two full-sized tennis courts and basketball hoops are perfect for sports enthusiasts. The elegant clubhouse has a fully equipped kitchen, indoor tables, and an outdoor grilling area under a spacious gazebo. With these exceptional amenities a few steps away, every day feels like a vacation.

Market Overview

Key West, FL Real Estate Information

Median Listing Price

$1,500,000

Median Price Per Sq Ft

$1,100

Average Days on Market

84

Median Price of Sold Homes

$1,100,000

Home Ownership Percentage

46.2%

Median Rent

$3,700

Homes in Shark Key, FL

5 Real Estate Facts About Shark Key, FL

  • Shark Key homes showcase custom designs, ranging from Caribbean, Mediterranean, and Contemporary architectural styles.

  • These high-end homes for sale in Shark Key, FL, range from $2.5M to $6.2M, presenting a premier level of luxury.

  • Shark Key, Florida, homes for sale feature sophisticated interior living spaces measuring 2,200 to 5,300 square feet. They can comfortably accommodate up to five bedrooms and six bathrooms.

  • The expansive lot sizes in Shark Key, Florida, range from 0.29 to 1.05 acres, allowing for a stunning outdoor oasis ideal for relaxation and entertaining.

  • A quarterly HOA fee of $1,360 maintains Shark Key’s top-tier amenities, ensuring a pristine and exclusive island lifestyle.

On the map

Shark Key, FL Map

Shark Key is a small island in the lower Florida Keys, roughly seven miles east of Key West. It is north of U.S. 1, near mile marker 11.5. It sits between the Saddlebunch Keys and Big Coppitt Key.

Take the next step

Do you want to visit this location?

Whether you’re considering your very first island home or you’re a seasoned Keys homeowner looking to buy, sell or add a new property to your portfolio, I’m here to help. Ready to get started? Let’s talk.

Meet the locals

Who Lives in Key West, FL

Population

26,078

Median Age

44.9

Median Household Income

$126,028

Households

11,161

Household size

2.24

Cost of living

148.2

Entertainment

Things to do in Shark Key, FL

Bobalu's Southern Café

Enjoy authentic Southern comfort food with a Florida twist, from savory fried chicken to spicy gumbo.

Key West Golf Club

Play a round on this lush, 18-hole course with a tropical setting and rolling greens.

Mel Fisher Museum

Discover priceless artifacts that bring the Golden Age of Piracy to life with legendary shipwreck treasures.

Mallory Square

With street performers, local vendors, and stunning sunsets, it's a must-see Key West experience.

Activities

Activities in Shark Key, FL

ActivityPhoneWebsite
Jolly Roger II Boat Charter305-747-4692Website
Paddlin' Madeleine940-768-8128Website
Conch Golf Cart & Scooter Rentals Key West305-676-2946Website