Overview

Luxury Homes for Sale in Lower Sugarloaf Key, FL

Lower Sugarloaf Key, FL, offers a peaceful, residential lifestyle, blending waterfront homes and lush natural landscapes.

Sugarloaf Key is a U-shaped island that wraps around the Atlantic Ocean. It has two separate island communities with Lower Sugarloaf Key, as the name suggests, forming its lower arm. It is smaller yet more populated, creating a lively community atmosphere. The unique street layout gives nearly every home for sale in Lower Sugarloaf Key direct water access. Despite the quiet, secluded vibe, you’re only a short drive from the vibrant energy and attractions of Key West.

BOATER’S PARADISE: The streets in Lower Sugarloaf Key are laid out in peaceful cul-de-sacs with calm lagoons between each lane. This means every home has a convenient launch point for paddleboards, kayaks, and canoes. Many properties also have private docks and boat lifts in their backyard, making it easy to explore the backcountry waters or out to the open ocean. Whether fishing, cruising at sunset, or enjoying the views from your deck, Lower Sugarloaf Key makes you experience the best of waterfront living.

SKYDIVE ADVENTURE: Lower Sugarloaf Key is more than just a quiet retreat – it’s also home to one of the most exciting activities in the Florida Keys. Just down the same road as Perky Bat Tower is Skydive Key West, where you can experience “the most scenic drop in America.” After a flight over the spectacular turquoise waters, you’ll leap from the plane with a seasoned instructor. The highly experienced staff members have over 60 years of combined aviation experience, ensuring a safe and unforgettable experience for every jumper.

BUILD YOUR DREAM HOME: If you’ve ever dreamed of designing your own paradise, Lower Sugarloaf Key real estate offers the opportunity to do just that. Several buildable lots are offered in the market to create your dream home in one of the most stunning locations in the Florida Keys. With a blank canvas, there’s plenty of room to make your vision come to life, be it a spacious family house with multiple beds, an infinity pool in the backyard, or even guest houses. This prime real estate offers canal frontage, access to open waters, and spectacular views.

Market Overview

Key West, FL Real Estate Information

Median Listing Price

$1,500,000

Median Price Per Sq Ft

$1,100

Average Days on Market

84

Median Price of Sold Homes

$1,100,000

Home Ownership Percentage

46.2%

Median Rent

$3,700

Homes in Lower Sugarloaf Key, FL

5 Real Estate Facts About Lower Sugarloaf Key, FL

The stunning custom homes for sale in Lower Sugarloaf Key range between $998,000 and $5.4M.
Lower Sugarloaf Key homes for sale range from 1,100 to 3,000+ square feet, with layouts featuring two to five bedrooms and two to four bathrooms.
Property lots in Lower Sugarloaf Key, FL, span from 0.19 to 1.31 acres, providing ample space for outdoor living.
Sugarloaf Key, FL, real estate includes vacant lots listed between $699,000 and $899,000.
These land parcels range from 0.27 to 1.7 acres and include direct access to open water, offering stunning views.

Find Your Home

Latest Homes for Sale in Lower Sugarloaf Key, FL

Contingent/Show

On the map

Lower Sugarloaf Key, FL Map

Lower Sugarloaf Key is about 15 miles east of Key West between Saddlebunch Key and Cudjoe Key. U.S. Highway 1 crosses the island at about mile markers 16.5–17.5.

Take the next step

Do you want to visit this location?

Whether you’re considering your very first island home or you’re a seasoned Keys homeowner looking to buy, sell or add a new property to your portfolio, I’m here to help. Ready to get started? Let’s talk.