Featured image for the Luxury Homes for Sale in Big Pine Key, FL Community Guide Page
Credit: Image by Gene Gallin | Unsplash
Overview

Luxury Homes for Sale in Big Pine Key, FL

Big Pine Key offers an idyllic island lifestyle surrounded by the beauty of the Florida Key Deer Preserve.

This scenic island is home to the endangered Key deer, and local conservation efforts help protect them. A section of the highway is elevated and fenced, creating a safe corridor for these mammals to cross underneath. Homes for sale on Big Pine Key offer an ideal gateway for exploring the Lower Keys and the entire Florida Keys. With numerous waterfront properties, you’ll have direct access to the inviting, clear waters of the Atlantic Ocean and the Gulf of Mexico. Whether as a vacation escape or a permanent residence, Big Pine Key invites you to enjoy a true island lifestyle.

WILDLIFE ENCOUNTERS: Florida’s Big Pine Key is the proud home of the National Key Deer Refuge, established in 1957 to protect these small, unique white-tailed deer. The area covers over 9,000 acres of mangrove forests, wetlands, pine rocklands, and hardwood hammocks, creating a haven for many other animals. Key Deer Boulevard leads to the Blue Hole, a freshwater oasis where Key deer come to drink. An observation platform offers the perfect spot to observe alligators, turtles, and birds, while a shaded walking trail gives visitors a closer look at the island’s remarkable habitats.

ISLAND AMENITIES: Big Pine Key, FL, real estate offers an island lifestyle without sacrificing modern conveniences. Along U.S. 1, you’ll find everything from Winn-Dixie grocery store, fresh catches at Generations Seafood and Produce, and unique ingredients at Tindahan, The Little Asian Store. The Big Pine Key Flea Market is perfect for picking up local goods, while dive shops, fishing stores, and boat repair services cater to all things water-related. Bars and restaurants offer laid-back dining, so whether you’re grabbing supplies or unwinding with friends, Big Pine Key has everything for easy island living.

WATER ADVENTURES: Big Pine Key makes exploring the crystal-clear waters of the Atlantic and the Gulf hassle-free with quick-access neighborhood boat ramps. Kayaking and snorkeling are popular here, and the surrounding area has plenty of fantastic fishing spots. Sail away to discover backcountry beaches or head to renowned diving areas teeming with marine life and colorful coral reefs. Big Pine Key, FL, homes for sale give water lovers the ideal gateway to endless Florida Keys adventures.

Market Overview

Key West, FL Real Estate Information

Median Listing Price

$1,500,000

Median Price Per Sq Ft

$1,100

Average Days on Market

84

Median Price of Sold Homes

$1,100,000

Home Ownership Percentage

46.2%

Median Rent

$3,700

Homes in Big Pine Key, FL

5 Real Estate Facts About Big Pine Key, FL

  • Big Pine Key, Florida, real estate ranges from prime gulf-front and canal-front properties to peaceful inland lots.

  • Homes for sale in Big Pine Key, Florida, include charming cottages, mobile houses, elevated single-family homes on stilts, and luxurious custom residences.

  • Homes for sale in Big Pine Key range from $450,000 to $4.9M, offering options for various budgets.

  • The interior living spaces of Big Pine Key, FL, homes vary from 654 to 3,700 square feet.

  • Lot sizes range from 0.17 to 0.44 acres, allowing room to enjoy their island oasis.

On the map

Big Pine Key, FL Map

Big Pine Key is in the lower Florida Keys, about 30 miles northeast of Key West. It’s part of Monroe County, between Torch Key and No Name Key. It is accessible via the Overseas Highway (U.S. 1) at mile markers 29.5–33.

Take the next step

Do you want to visit this location?

Whether you’re considering your very first island home or you’re a seasoned Keys homeowner looking to buy, sell or add a new property to your portfolio, I’m here to help. Ready to get started? Let’s talk.

Meet the locals

Who Lives in Key West, FL

Population

26,078

Median Age

44.9

Median Household Income

$126,028

Households

11,161

Household size

2.24

Cost of living

148.2

Entertainment

Things to do in Big Pine Key, FL

Sandspur Beach

Unwind, swim, and enjoy the serene beauty of the Florida Keys in this mile-long stretch of soft sand in Bahia Honda State Park.

Big Pine Key Community Park

Bond with family and friends outdoors with playgrounds, tennis courts, and walking tracks.

Big Pine Rooster

Indulge in delicious steaks, seafood, and pasta in this local favorite spot with a relaxed atmosphere.

Fred C. Manillo Wildlife Trail

Take a 250-yard journey through one of the Florida Keys' unique natural habitats, leading to a wildlife observation platform.

Activities

Activities in Big Pine Key, FL

ActivityPhoneWebsite
Sixto Fishing Charters305-316-9127Website
Blue Balance Paddle Board970-596-5681Website
Key West Fly Fishing Guides305-304-3768Website