Featured image for the Luxury Homes for Sale in Upper Sugarloaf Key, FL Community Guide Page
Credit: Image by Tolga Ulkan | Unsplash
Overview

Luxury Homes for Sale in Upper Sugarloaf Key, FL

The Sugarloaf Key area is a popular destination for tourists who prefer the quieter and more remote side of the Keys.

Upper Sugarloaf Key, FL, is one of the two sections of Sugarloaf Key. This neighborhood is livelier than Lower Sugarloaf because it has more businesses, schools, diners, and recreational spots. Residents enjoy the exclusive feel of the island. It is the perfect balance of a laid-back yet fun lifestyle because even though this is the more tranquil side of the Keys, residents can still have fun with the local recreational activities and travel to Key West, Marathon Key, or Key Largo for additional fun. Sugarloaf Key real estate comprises homes ideal for individuals and groups like families. Home features include carports, stainless steel appliances, cathedral ceilings, quartz countertops, metal roof, french doors, and central air and heat pump. If you want to learn more about this vibrant neighborhood, don’t hesitate to call us. We’d love to show you around the beautiful area of Upper Sugarloaf Key, FL.

PLEASANT CLIMATE: Living in Upper Sugarloaf means sunny summers and warm winters. The pleasant climate provides plenty of opportunities for outdoor activities. Because of this, there is an abundance of lush green spaces, native plants, and wildlife in the area. If you love adventures, chasing thrill, and exploring what nature offers, choose Upper Sugarloaf Key homes for sale. There are no dull moments here!

ABUNDANT RECREATIONAL ACTIVITIES: If you’re a fan of recreational activities, Upper Sugarloaf Key, FL, offers many recreational options for residents and tourists. For starters, you can book a guided tour of the island, visit the local tourist spots like Bat Tower, then conquer your fear of heights at Sugarloaf Key Jumping Bridge, or camp at The Lazy Lakes RV Resort or The Sugarloaf KOA campground. Outdoor activities are not a problem here, all you have to do is step outside, and the adventure will find you.

BOATING AND FISHING DESTINATION: Upper Sugarloaf Key is a popular boating and fishing destination. Many fishing charters and boating tours operate here, boosting the area’s tourism. Scuba divers also love Upper Sugarloaf because it is part of the Florida Keys National Marine Museum. Marine life is rich here, and the warm waters are very comforting. There’s no reason not to love Upper Sugarloaf Key, FL.

Market Overview

Key West, FL Real Estate Information

Median Listing Price

$1,500,000

Median Price Per Sq Ft

$1,100

Average Days on Market

84

Median Price of Sold Homes

$1,100,000

Home Ownership Percentage

46.2%

Median Rent

$3,700

Homes in Upper Sugarloaf Key, FL

5 Real Estate Facts About Upper Sugarloaf Key, FL

  • Upper Sugarloaf Key homes for sale range from $699,000 to as expensive as $1,500,000.

  • Most properties typically have three to four bedrooms and bathrooms of two to three.

  • The internal living spaces for Upper Sugarloaf Key, FL, homes commonly measure from 1,143 sqft to 2,464 sqft.

  • The lot sizes of many residential properties in the neighborhood span from 10,018 sqft to 0.69 acres.

  • Sugarloaf Key, FL, real estate includes recently built (2017) and recently renovated homes from the late 1900s.

On the map

Upper Sugarloaf Key, FL Map

Upper Sugarloaf Key, FL, is between Park Key and Cudjoe Key. You can get to the island on the Overseas Highway.

Take the next step

Do you want to visit this location?

Whether you’re considering your very first island home or you’re a seasoned Keys homeowner looking to buy, sell or add a new property to your portfolio, I’m here to help. Ready to get started? Let’s talk.

Meet the locals

Who Lives in Key West, FL

Population

26,078

Median Age

44.9

Median Household Income

$126,028

Households

11,161

Household size

2.24

Cost of living

148.2

Entertainment

Things to do in Upper Sugarloaf Key, FL

Sky Dive Key West

Just a short drive from Upper Sugar Loaf, you can experience a breathtaking thrill and an absolutely epic skydive in beautiful Sugarloaf Key, FL!

Sugarloaf Lodge Marina

The spot for water activities! Enjoy boating, fishing, and watching scenic views of the Florida Keys.

Capt. Clint Moore

An immersive guided tour around Sugarloaf Key and Lower Florida Keys.

Mangrove Mama

A seafood restaurant that has been part of the Upper Sugarloaf identity. They offer mouthwatering fresh seafood in a laid-back setting.

Activities

Activities in Upper Sugarloaf Key, FL

ActivityPhoneWebsite
Skydive Key West(305) 396-8806Website
Native Guidance(305) 393-4153Website
Key Flat Charters(305) 304-3152Website
Back Country Boat Rentals(720) 480-0557Website
Get Up and Go Kayaking(786) 964-5778Website
Key West Fly Fishing(305) 304-5880Website