Explore Middle Keys Florida

Middle Keys Florida Neighborhood Guides

Discover the luxury communities in Middle Keys, Florida. Check each neighborhood page and learn about the essential facts and lifestyle of the area. Feel free to talk to us with any questions.

Credit: Photo by Frans van Heerden on Pexels | Source

Luxury Homes for Sale in Middle Keys, FL

The Middle Keys is a beautiful subsection of the Florida Keys in Monroe County, Florida.

From Duck Key to Marathon, the Middle Keys boasts a charming laid-back lifestyle from days gone by. Nestled amid the Gulf of Mexico and Atlantic Ocean, The Middle Keys are a series of tiny islands that start around Mile Marker 65 in Long Key and run to Mile Marker 47, the beginning of the Seven Mile Bridge. Visitors and homebuyers alike are attracted to the Middle Keys central location. Whether looking to spend a day listening to live music in Key West or exploring the John Pennekamp Coral Reef State Park in Key Largo, you’re only a short drive away. If you’re searching for great homes for sale, Middle Keys, FL, that is where I specialize. Call me today and let’s get started finding your dream home in paradise.

TIME TO UNWIND: An island getaway, Middle Keys homes for sale have endless aquatic adventure all around. Whether you enjoy boating, fishing, scuba diving or snorkeling, there are plenty of opportunities for you to explore. When not on the water, there is always something new and exciting, from festivals, concert events and holiday celebrations, there is no shortage of family-friendly events. From Bahia Honda to Sombrero Beach, with Middle Keys homes for sale, you are only a short drive or walk to spending the day at the beach soaking up the sun and salty air. Life may be slower paced here, but that doesn’t mean it’s boring.

COMMUNITY APPEAL: With fewer than 12,000 full-time residents in the Middle Keys and most businesses locally owned and operated, no one is a stranger, and everyone is welcome. A home in paradise not only offers refuge from everyday hustle and bustle but also the opportunity to enjoy the social fabric inherent to island life. While some may prefer spending the day on the water or with their favorite book amongst the palm trees and pelicans, Middle Keys homes for sale also include many opportunities to get out and spend time volunteering for non-profits and charity groups. If you’re looking to escape the rat race and big city life, you will love the relaxed lifestyle and sense of community that comes with living in Middle Florida Keys homes for sale.

WEEKLY RENTALS: Marathon and Key Colony Beach are the only two cities in the Florida Keys that allow weekly rentals, per county ordinance all other municipalities within the Keys require a minimum 28-day rental, except for a few one-off allowances. For homebuyers looking to rent their home when not in residence, homes for sale Middle Keys FL, specifically Marathon and Key Colony Beach, are likely to yield the highest return and therefore are the most sought-after addresses. Please call me to discuss the best home for you if you plan to utilize it as a vacation rental. I can also put you in touch with the top vacation rental management companies.

Market Overview

Middle Keys, FL Real Estate Information

Median Listing Price


Median Price Per Sq Ft


Average Days on Market


Median Price of Sold Homes


Home Ownership Percentage


Median Rent


Homes in Middle Keys, FL

10 Real Estate Facts About Homes For Sale in Middle Keys, FL

  • There were just under 500 residential transactions in 2022 in the Middle Keys
  • Average Middle Keys price for homes sold in 2022 was $1,115,000
  • 26 Middle Keys homes closed in the $1.00-1.09 million range in 2022
  • 34 Middle Keys homes closed in the $650,000 to 699,000 range in 2022
  • Highest price home to sell in the Middle Keys in 2022 was $12.2 million
  • Lowest price home to sell in the Middle Keys in 2022 was $65,000
  • 33 Middle Keys homes closed in the $550,000 to 599,000 range in 2022
  • Median Middle Keys price for homes sold in 2022 was $812,000
  • Middle Keys average market time in 2022 was 51 days
  • 25 Middle Keys homes closed in the $1.20-1.29 million range in 2022
On the map

Middle Keys Neighborhoods Map

The Middle Keys are made up of many different islands, both unnamed and named, including Duck Key, Key Colony Beach, Pigeon Key, Fat Deer Key, Fiesta Key, Key Vaca, Grassy Key, Craig Key, Crawl Key, Long Key, Boot Key, Long Point Key, Knight’s Key, and Conch Key. The Miami airport is just over two hours away and the Key West airport is just over an hour away.

a drawn out map of Middle Keys Florida
Middle Keys Florida Map

Middle Keys Florida on the Map

Click on any neighborhood for a brief introduction

Take the next step

Ready to take the next step?

As your dedicated real estate partner, I will provide a well-executed and enjoyable experience. I draw on my professional work ethic, expert industry knowledge, and genuine love for what I do to help my clients achieve their real estate goals. If you are ready to buy, sell, or invest in the Keys, you need an informed, trusted and determined real estate partner who knows the landscape and has an outstanding network of contacts. I’ll focus on understanding your needs; then, I’ll confidently guide you to the opportunities that are right for you.

Meet the locals

Who Lives in Middle Keys, FL



Median Age


Median Household Income




Household size


Cost of living



Things to do in Middle Keys

Porky's Bayside Restaurant and Marina

A casual waterfront restaurant offering BBQ, seafood, and drinks in comfortable surroundings.

Turtle Hospital

A sea turtle center for rehab and rescue that offers guided tours and a souvenir shop

Keys Strength And Conditioning

Get a good workout and meet with friendly trainers as you flex your muscles and stretch yourself. This fitness facility has upgraded equipment waiting for you.

Marathon Skate Park

Wheels up and boards down. Skate your way through this skate park and make friends as you learn new tricks.


Schools in Middle Keys

Stanley Switlik Elementary SchoolK - 5Public
Marathon High School6 - 12Public