Featured image for the Luxury Homes for Sale in Stock Island, FL Community Guide Page
Credit: Image by Daria Nepriakhina πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡¦ | Unsplash
Overview

Luxury Homes for Sale in Stock Island, FL

Stock Island is the charming island you hit right before reaching Key West, Florida, on US 1.

Often described as a working community, it offers a taste of Old Key West. You’ll find working fishing and shrimping boats, vibrant murals, and quirky shops that give the area its unique, laid-back vibe. On the northern side, you’ll find the only golf course in Key West, the lush Key West Botanical Garden, and the main campus of Florida Keys Community College. The southern side is bustling with mobile homes for sale, lively docks, and marinas with live-aboard boats. Though primarily residential, it boasts a rustic charm, making it a delightful place to explore.

COASTAL LIFESTYLE: Stock Island’s deep-water marinas and boat yards provide a full range of amenities. They offer dry rack boat storage, wet slip options, and fuel services. Beyond just docking, they are also gateways to water-based activities. Go on thrilling scuba adventures, set sail and explore the diverse ecosystems, or rent a boat and engage in sport fishing. Many also feature a pool, event spaces, and a private beach with incredible views. Houses for sale in Stock Island, Florida, allow you to indulge in your passion for the ocean, enjoy top-notch amenities, and live an exciting coastal lifestyle.

FRESH SEAFOOD AND LOCAL FLAVOR: Fishing and shrimping boats have long been a staple in Stock Island, Florida, providing the freshest seafood for local restaurants. This makes dining here worth the stop or drive. Hogfish Bar and Grill is a “locals” spot offering seafood straight from the ocean to your plate. The dock-to-dish concept of The Docks ensures that every meal is as fresh as it gets, with daily selections from Keys Fresh Seafood Market steps away. Beard & Brews offers a unique vibe with a friendly barber parlor atmosphere, a pool table, and a great beer, wine, spirits, and coffee selection.

ARTISTIC HAVEN: Stock Island, Florida, real estate has attracted creative minds, resulting in a thriving arts scene. Fine arts studios, nautical antique shops, and galleries offer a glimpse into local talent. While in the area, join the Mural Art Tour, a self-guided journey through the colorful murals that bring the island’s walls to life. The Key West Tropical Forest & Botanical Garden also hosts a garden exhibit featuring outdoor pieces made of recycled materials. The “I Love Stock Island Festival” adds to the cultural richness with a five-day celebration of local community, culture, and art.

Market Overview

Stock Island, FL Real Estate Information

Median Listing Price

$655,212

Median Price Per Sq Ft

$653

Average Days on Market

76

Median Price of Sold Homes

$528,000

Home Ownership Percentage

27.1%

Median Rent

$1,228

Homes in Stock Island, FL

5 Real Estate Facts About Stock Island, FL

  • The gated residential community of Key West Golf Club occupies nearly one-quarter of Stock Island, Florida. It offers single-family homes and townhouses with scenic views of the golf course.

  • Homes for sale in the golf course area of Stock Island, Florida, range from $565,000 to $1.8M, and their sizes vary between 780 and 1,600 square feet.

  • On the southern side is a mix of mobile homes and townhouses priced between $279,000 and $1.9M.

  • The living spaces of these Stock Island, Florida, houses for sale range from 760 to 2,100 square feet.

  • Stock Island real estate also includes live-aboard and non-live-aboard boat slips from $265,000 to $995,000. These provide easy access to the Gulf and the Atlantic.

On the map

Stock Island, FL Map

Stock Island is in the lower Florida Keys. It is east of Key West, separated by the Cow Key Channel. It’s located at markers 4–6 on US 1.

Take the next step

Do you want to visit this location?

Whether you’re considering your very first island home or you’re a seasoned Keys homeowner looking to buy, sell or add a new property to your portfolio, I’m here to help. Ready to get started? Let’s talk.

Meet the locals

Who Lives in Stock Island, FL

Population

4,436

Median Age

34.6

Median Household Income

$78,554

Households

1,663

Household size

2.74

Cost of living

148.2

Entertainment

Things to do in Stock Island, FL

Key West Tropical Forest & Botanical Garden

Enjoy a tranquil stroll through lush trees, shrubs, and palms, including impressive "champion trees."

Key West Golf Club

Tee off on the only Caribbean golf course designed by Rees Jones, featuring an 18-hole, 6,500-yard par 70 layout.

Boyd's Key West RV Campground

Relax by the resort-style pool, unwind at the Tiki lounge, and enjoy the views from spacious RV and tent sites.

Stock Island Yacht Club and Marina

It offers premium amenities, docking facilities, and direct access to the beautiful waters of the Florida Keys.

Activities

Activities in Stock Island, FL

ActivityPhoneWebsite
Robbie's of Key West Marina305-294-1124Website
Ski Key West305-296-2210Website
Fun in the Sun Rentals and Boat Charters305-587-3499Website