Explore Key Colony Beach, FL

Key Colony Beach, FL Neighborhood Guides

Explore our featured Key Colony, FL luxury communities. Check each page to get detailed information on each house type and lifestyle. Don’t hesitate to contact us with any questions.

Credit: Photo by Tracy Chacksfield | Source


Luxury Homes for Sale in Key Colony Beach, Florida Keys, Florida

Known as “The Gem of the Florida Keys,” Key Colony Beach is a small close-knit community where many homeowners enjoy their residence primarily during “Snowbird Season.”

With only one small causeway on and off Key Colony Beach, blink as you are passing by on Overseas Highway and you are sure to miss this secluded island enclave. Key Colony Beach FL real estate for sale offers a variety of options and price points for those looking to experience a walkable and bikeable island community. Renowned for having some of the most meticulously maintained properties in all the Keys and one of the few islands with a white sandy beach, homes for sale Key Colony Beach, FL are always in demand. Most homes in Key Colony Beach are on 100’ wide canals, with private docks starting at 30’ to over 75’ right out your back door there’s no need to drive back and forth to a marina, you’ll be on the Atlantic or in the Gulf of Mexico in mere minutes. Give me a call about homes for sale in Key Colony Beach FL and we will find the perfect home for you.

COMFORTABLE CLIMATE: The Florida Keys are known for year round balmy weather, which makes homes for sale in Key Colony Beach, FL all the more desirable. Being located in a tropical environment, it is an escape for many, where winter temperatures rarely dip below 70 degrees and typically hover in the mid-70s. Spring continues the delightful weather with only a slight uptick in the daily average. Due to the presence of steady trade winds, summers in the Keys are far more tolerable and less oppressive than in mainland Florida, with people flocking to enjoy the gentle breezes and warm turquoise waters. The weather alone makes it easy to understand why so many take interest in the Key Colony Beach realty Florida Keys market.

BEACHES & VIEWS: The Florida Keys are one of the most beautiful areas of the country and the most tropical. The Keys are a chain of limestone islands but offer very few sandy shorelines, to many people’s surprise. If having access to a white sand beach is a priority, then you will want to consider homes for sale in Key Colony Beach, FL. Key Colony Beach is one of the few areas in all the Keys to offer homeowners the opportunity to have your own sandy beach. Key Colony Beach is also known as a place to watch breathtaking sunsets at the appropriately named Sunset Park. Be sure to check out Key Colony Beach realty Florida Keys to explore all the splendor the island offers.

COLLECTION OF ACTIVITIES: Key Colony Beach offers a variety of things to participate in for residents and visitors. Spend the afternoon at the Key Colony Beach 9-Hole Par 3 golf course or bike to a game of tennis or pickleball. Looking for an opportunity to socialize, join the Key Colony Beach Fishing & Boating Club or Community Association, both participate, support and/or organize many of the annual community events such as the KCB Christmas Boat Parade, Clam Bake, KCB Days, Kids Fishing Tournament and more. When considering houses for sale in Key Colony Beach, Florida, know that plenty of activities are right out your front door. And when you want to relax after a day of exploring Key Colony Beach, FL real estate for sale, head over to the Cabana Club for a beverage and dip in the pool or unwind on your private dock watching marine life swim by.

Market Overview

Key Colony Beach, FL Real Estate Information

Median Listing Price


Median Price Per Sq Ft


Average Days on Market


Median Price of Sold Homes


Home Ownership Percentage


Median Rent


Homes in Key Colony Beach, FL

10 Real Estate Facts About Homes for Sale in Key Colony Beach, FL

  • Most expensive single-family home in 2022 sold for $4,799,000
  • Most expensive condo in 2022 sold for $1,225,000
  • Most expensive half-duplex in 2022 sold for $1,600,000
  • 5,185 sqft was largest size single-family home sold in 2022
  • 1,901 sqft was largest size condo sold in 2022
  • Least expensive single-family home in 2022 sold for $845,000
  • Least expensive condo in 2022 sold for $235,000
  • Least expensive half-duplex in 2022 sold for $299,000
  • 1,155 was smallest size single-family home sold in 2022
  • 550 sqft was smallest size condo sold in 2022
On the map

Key Colony Beach, FL Neighborhoods Map

Situated on the Atlantic Ocean at Mile Marker 53.5 near Vaca Cut, Key Colony Beach sits on what was once called Shelter Key. The island encompasses an area of 286 acres, comprising of just 17 residential streets and eleven 100’ or wider deep-water canals. The island has approximately 1500 residential properties, yet only 800 full-time residents. From Miami, it is just over a two-hour drive and from Key West just over an hour drive. The 25 MPH speed limit is strictly enforced on the island.

a drawn out map of Key Coloney Beach neighborhood
Key Colony Beach, FL Map

Key Colony Beach, FL Interactive Map

Click on any neighborhood for a brief introduction

Take the next step

Ready to take the next step?

As your dedicated real estate partner, I will provide a well-executed and enjoyable experience. I draw on my professional work ethic, expert industry knowledge, and genuine love for what I do to help my clients achieve their real estate goals. If you are ready to buy, sell, or invest in the Keys, you need an informed, trusted and determined real estate partner who knows the landscape and has an outstanding network of contacts. I’ll focus on understanding your needs; then, I’ll confidently guide you to the opportunities that are right for you.

Meet the locals

Who Lives in Key Colony Beach, FL



Median Age


Median Household Income




Household size


Cost of living



Things to do in Key Colony Beach, FL

Havana Jack's Oceanside Restaurant and Bar

A laidback shoreline location with an ocean view patio, where you can enjoy cocktails and live music. They even feature a cigar menu.

History of Diving Museum

Located in Islamorada, a small but well-curated museum with pieces, exhibits, and paraphernalia demonstrating the development of diving throughout history.

Florida Keys Aquarium Encounters

Interactive aquatic experiences for all ages offering snorkeling, diving, feeding activities, touch tanks and more.

Overseas Pub & Grill

Founded in 1937, stop by for a bite to eat, live entertainment and check out a locals’ favorite. It is said Ernest Hemingway used to be a customer.


Schools in Key Colony Beach, FL

Stanley Switlik Elementary SchoolPK - 5Public
Marathon High School6 - 12Public