Luxury Homes for Sale in Stirrup Key, Florida Keys, Florida

Nestled in the Gulf of Mexico, the community of Stirrup Key is one of the Middle Key’s best kept secrets.

Stirrup Key Marathon, FL is so off the beaten path it’s rare for anyone to simply stumble across this neighborhood. For those that do end up wandering down the mangrove lined causeway leading to this hidden treasure, they’ll be left to ponder what lies behind the gatehouse. Sitting on roughly 60 acres, with 105 mostly developed residential lots, Stirrup Key Marathon, FL is one of only a handful of gated neighborhoods in the Middle Keys. Locals are drawn to Stirrup Key for not only the privacy a gated community offers, but also the larger than typical homesites and beautiful open water views many of the homes offer. If Stirrup Key sounds like what you’ve been searching for, let’s connect and schedule some showings today.

GOOD CLIMATE: The Florida Keys are known for year round balmy weather, which makes Stirrup Key all the more desirable. Being located in a tropical environment, the Keys offer the perfect winter escape, where temperatures rarely dip below 70 degrees and typically hover in the mid-70’s. Spring continues the delightful weather with only a slight uptick in the daily average. Due to the presence of steady trade winds, summers in the Keys are far more tolerable and less oppressive than mainland Florida, with people flocking to enjoy the gentle breezes and warm turquoise waters. The weather alone makes it easy to understand why so many look to purchase a home in the Keys.

HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION: When you own property in Stirrup Key, you are a part of the Stirrup Key homeowners association (HOA). Surprisingly, for such a luxury community, the HOA fees are very affordable. One of the top reasons many homebuyers consider Stirrup Key is that the HOA rules and regulations strictly forbid any sort of vacation rental, with only annual rentals permitted. Without the weekly or monthly turnover associated with vacation rentals, residents of Stirrup Key Marathon FL are genuinely a tight-knit group, where regularly scheduled dinner nights at a neighbor’s home is an organized community event.

FULFILLED LIFE: Stirrup Key is the ideal location for those seeking a quiet and peaceful life where egrets and white ibises are about the only trespassers. With two lakes totaling two acres and a five-acre lagoon featuring two recirculating channels and a 61-dock marina, Stirrup Key, Marathon, FL provides homeowners with an exceptionally comfortable lifestyle. This is a community where you feel worlds away from everything, yet are only minutes to shopping, dining, and all the recreational activities the tropics and Middle Keys offer.

Market Overview

Marathon, FL Real Estate Information

Median Listing Price

$1,300,000

Median Price Per Sq Ft

$838

Average Days on Market

123

Median Price of Sold Homes

$1,200,000

Home Ownership Percentage

51.4%

Median Rent

$1,332

Homes in Stirrup Key, Marathon, FL

5 Real Estate Facts About Stirrup Key, Marathon, FL

Most expensive Stirrup Key home sold in 2022 was $2.75M
Least expensive Stirrup Key home sold in 2022 was $1.16M
There were 5 homes sold in Sitrrup Key in 2022
There were 3 vacant lots sold in Stirrup Key in 2022
Stirrup Key homeowners association 2022 fees were less than $1500/yr

Find Your Home

Homes for Sale in Stirrup Key, Marathon, FL

Active

On the map

Stirrup Key Neighborhoods Map

Stirrup Key is located gulf side near Mile Marker 52.5, while accessible from 107^th Street, it is best to turn at Aviation Blvd from Overseas Highway and take that to Stirrup Key Road. The Florida Keys SPCA will be on the right-hand side just before Stirrup Key Road (left side). Follow Stirrup Key Rd to the gate house.

Take the next step

Ready to take the next step?

As your dedicated real estate partner, I will provide a well-executed and enjoyable experience. I draw on my professional work ethic, expert industry knowledge, and genuine love for what I do to help my clients achieve their real estate goals. If you are ready to buy, sell, or invest in the Keys, you need an informed, trusted and determined real estate partner who knows the landscape and has an outstanding network of contacts. I’ll focus on understanding your needs; then, I’ll confidently guide you to the opportunities that are right for you.

Meet the locals