Credit: Photo by Tracy Chacksfield | Source


Luxury Homes for Sale in Key Colony Beach Oceanfront, Florida Keys, Florida

Known as “The Gem of the Florida Keys,” Key Colony Beach is a small close-knit community where many enjoy their residence primarily during “Snowbird Season.”

With only one small causeway on and off Key Colony Beach, blink as you are passing by on Overseas Highway and you are sure to miss this secluded island enclave. Key Colony Beach offers a variety of luxury oceanfront condos for sale in Florida and amazing oceanfront single-family home options for those looking to experience a walkable and bikeable island community. Renowned for having some of the most meticulously maintained properties in all the Keys and one of the few islands with a white sandy beach, Key Colony Beach oceanfront condo rentals are always in demand. Give us a call today about oceanfront Key Colony Beach properties and we will find the perfect home for you.

WATERFRONT DEMAND: A waterfront property is one of the most coveted and desired when homebuyers are looking to invest in the Florida Keys. Whether you plan to reside here on a part-time basis or plan to retire and spend your days enjoying the beautiful climate, there are several reasons why oceanfront living in the Florida Keys is so desired. Not only is the year-round balmy weather attractive, if you are considering utilizing the home as a vacation rental, waterfront properties have the highest demand. For those that plan to rent their home when not in residence, be sure when considering affordable luxury oceanfront condos in Florida for sale that short-term or vacation rentals are permitted. Key Colony Beach oceanfront rentals are a great way to get a feel for everything happening in the area before you decide to invest.

VIEWS & LOCATIONS: Various studies have shown what many have believed for years: Living near or on the water is better for your health. Not only is waterfront living good for your health but is likely beneficial to your pocketbook. Your property’s location can significantly affect its potential value, with waterfront properties and open water views typically worth more than those that are not. The next time you’re considering buying a new property, think about whether an oceanfront condo Key Colony Beach FL might be suitable for you. Luxury oceanfront condos for sale in Florida and single-family homes are among the most popular choices for people looking to unwind from a stressful busy work life and enjoy the natural beauty of the Florida Keys.

RANGE OF ACTIVITIES: An island getaway, there is endless aquatic adventure all around. Whether you enjoy boating, fishing, scuba diving or snorkeling, there are plenty of opportunities for you to explore. When not on the water, there is always something new and exciting, from festivals, concert events and holiday celebrations, there is no shortage of family-friendly events. From Bahia Honda to Sombrero Beach, you are only a short drive or walk to spending the day at the beach soaking up the sun and salty air. Necessities are also within reach for day-to-day living, as grocery stores, restaurants and shopping are just around the corner. Life may be slower-paced here, but that doesn’t mean it’s boring.

Market Overview

Key Colony Beach, FL Real Estate Information

Median Listing Price


Median Price Per Sq Ft


Average Days on Market


Median Price of Sold Homes


Home Ownership Percentage


Median Rent


Homes in Key Colony Beach, FL

5 Real Estate Facts About Luxury Oceanfront Homes for Sale in Florida

  • Most expensive oceanfront sale in Key Colony Beach 2022 $1.225M
  • Least expensive oceanfront sale in Key Colony Beach 2022 $460K
  • Most expensive oceanfront sale in Key Colony Beach 2021 $6M
  • Least expensive oceanfront sale in Key Colony Beach 2021 $365K
  • 2022 saw only 15 oceanfront properties sell in Key Colony vs 44 in 2021
On the map

Key Colony Beach, FL Neighborhoods Map

Situated on the Atlantic Ocean at Mile Marker 53.5 near Vaca Cut, Key Colony Beach sits on what was once called Shelter Key. The island has just 17 residential streets and eleven 100’ or wider deep-water canals. From Miami, it is just over a two-hour drive and from Key West just over an hour drive. The 25 MPH speed limit is strictly enforced on the island.

Take the next step

Ready to take the next step?

As your dedicated real estate partner, I will provide a well-executed and enjoyable experience. I draw on my professional work ethic, expert industry knowledge, and genuine love for what I do to help my clients achieve their real estate goals. If you are ready to buy, sell, or invest in the Keys, you need an informed, trusted and determined real estate partner who knows the landscape and has an outstanding network of contacts. I’ll focus on understanding your needs; then, I’ll confidently guide you to the opportunities that are right for you.

Meet the locals

Who Lives in Key Colony Beach, FL



Median Age


Median Household Income




Household size


Cost of living



Things to do in Key Colony Beach, FL

Dolphin Connection

A marine education center that provides interactive programs where visitors can see firsthand how dolphins are being protected.

Irie Island Eats

A chill food truck, which offers specialty local dishes. Customers can enjoy eating outside and being surrounded by the beautiful scenery of the tropics.

Jolly Roger RV Resort

Jolly Roger's RV Campsite provides campers with 160 campsites, each of which comes equipped with 30 to 50 amps for powering electric equipment and other needs.

Key Colony Inn Restaurant

A walk to restaurant in Key Colony with a lounge area, cocktail bar, great happy hour and full lunch and dinner menu.


Schools near Key Colony Beach, FL

Stanley Switlik Elementary SchoolK - 5Public
Marathon High School6 - 12Public